Australian Monarchist League |

HOME

FAQ

Answers

If Australia is an independent nation, why should we include a British Queen in our political and legal system?

The description “British Queen” is used by republicans to deride what we are, which is a sovereign and independent nation, ‘under The Crown’. When we refer to The Queen in an Australian sense, we refer to her as Queen of Australia, not as Queen of Canada or Papua New Guinea or any of the other Realms. The fact that Her Majesty is Queen of sixteen Realms does not effect our day to day operations in Australia for, following appointment, the Governor-General assumes the constitutional authority of The Crown in Australia. Furthermore, we do not pay a salary or expenses to The Queen. The fact that The Queen is Queen of Australia does not mean that we take instructions from the British Government. We do not. It is our Government which makes requests of The Queen in so far as Australian affairs are concerned. Again, the proof that The Queen is subject to the will of the Australian people can be found in the fact that it was they, not the British, who had to decide on whether to retain The Queen or not.

FAQ

	Do you believe that Australia should become a republic?
	What do you think are the main reasons for Australia to become a republic?
	Do you believe it is important for Australia to maintain a link with the Queen? Why?
	Do you think that there are any problems in Australia due to our current constitutional monarchy system?
	Do you believe that our constitutional monarchy restricts Australia's freedom or national identity?
	In 1991 the High Court declared Britain to be a ‘foreign power’. Do you think there could be problems associated with becoming a republic? i.e. altering the constitution, altering currency
	Do you feel that running a referendum, and becoming a republic is a waste of valuable money and time?
	If you are for becoming a republic, do you think it should be prioritised? i.e. please list 1-5 what you feel the priorities of the Government should be: -inflation -fuel prices -the environment -increasing global links, particularly with Asia -becoming a republic
	Why do you think the 1999 republic referendum failed? Could the main reason be that John Howard was a monarchist?
	Why do you think the people of Australia who previously voted against a republic would decide to vote for a republic in the next referendum or would this not be the case?
	What type of republic system do you prefer? -American -1999 model -Not Sure/Other
	What are the disadvantages of adopting a republican system of government?
	Why was the 1999 Australian referendum for a republic unsuccessful?
	Do you think that a new referendum for a republic in Australia would be supported? If not, why?
	Do you think that a new preamble should be created accurately reflect Australia's status as an independent nation? If not, Why?
	If Australia is an independent nation, why should we include a British Queen in our political and legal system?
	Do you believe there will be a resurgence of the Australian Republic debate in the wake of Mr Turnbull's appointment as Liberal Leader?
	Do you believe Mr Turnbull’s past as campaigner for the Republican movement will affect the public’s perception of him (adversely or otherwise)?
	Do you think there has been a shift in public opinion since the referendum of 1999?
	The Republican’s main argument seems to be a need for an Australian Head of State. Comment?
	With becoming a republic being a waste of valuable money. What amount of money would be needed? And what are more important issues the money should be spent on? thank you for assignment
	I do not wish to see the Governor General replaced by a politically motivated President. Then we have to have a vice president. The monarchy as it stands in Australia has no influence on Australia's constitution, or politics or legislation and to me a Republic will give more powers to the politicians, the courts and police. The Queen her decendants and the Governor General are a political. The people's umpire if and when, rarely required. Above politics. An emotive Republican agenda, do you want a head of state that is Australian born. Well - there is no terminology for Head of State, it is a Republican concept. Malcolm Turnbull is trying to gain votes. But he does not fool us all. OK. What advantage to the Australian citizenship will a Republic bring? Bugger all I feel.
	My father was born in England and I have been told by him and my grandfather in Scotland that we have direct relation to Robert the Bruce. I was wondering if you are able to assist me with tracing back my history?
	I'm interested in how the Crown is capable of protecting the Australian people from Australian politicians. In which circumstances may the Crown do this, how, and if Australia were to become a rupublic, what control over the Australian people would the politicians, or, President have?
	I'm interested in joining the Australian Monarchist League, however I'm not sure if I should get a trial or standard?? What information are we given in our membership pack??
	In becoming a republic would it pose any outstanding threat to Australian national security or safety?
	Do you as I do suspect a link between a republic (desired from the top rather than the bottom) and multiculturalism, that is, that hard-core multiculturalists will not believe their objective truly accomplished until all vestiges of Australia's British heritage eliminated, thus relegating so called Anglo-Australians to just another ethnic group?
	Do you have any arguments against the republic that DON'T rely on the 'it was the Australian people who decided to go against the republic and keep the Queen' argument? ...for a monarchist group you don't seem to have many reasons for Australia not to become a republic.
	Why isnt there a political party based on monarchism preserving the Crown. We have the Liberals, Labour, Nationals, Greens, Christian Democrats why not a Monarchist Party a political party with MP's and senators or even one day a PM.
	Hi, I came across your website as I'm looking for a t-shirt and spare wheel cover that has the flag and words like "Save the flag" - do you know where I can find such items ? Incidentally I previously voted to retain the constitution and won't waiver on this question, however this website and cause is very monarchist and the crown which is not quite where my loyalties lay, I'm thinking you may be doing a diservice to the cause by not broadening your message, for example the store sells items not referring to the constition or flag directly but to the crown. These are items the Ulster Loyalists would love but as I say it seems to have your cause and that of the Governor General a lot narrower than it needs to be regards Antone Homan (a brit by origin)
	Australia is no longer a federation?
	As most republicans are only republicans because the Queen lives over seas do you believe it is possible to have an alternative to a republic put forward. That being that Australia have a resident monarch (not shared) who will take office of king/Queen after the current Queen passes.
	Do you believe that Australia could adopt its own resident monarch (i.e. replacing the GG with a monarch) after the Queens reign?
	Do you believe suppourt for a republic is increasing or decreasing within Australia?
	The WA separation act 2003/4 removes Her majesty QE 2nd her heirs and successors and subjects, Removes the Crown of the UK and removes and substitutes the oath of allegience..... No referendum was held. What does the preamble say about indissoluble part. The constitution seems pretty well fractured to me.
	If a member of the royal family came and lived in Australia, and built a special bond with the people of Australia, do you feel its possible to alter Australias act of succession to allow that member of the royal family to become Australia's next King or Queen. Thus giving us a resident monarch as well as allowing Australia to maintain its current constitution.
	Hello just wondering can you fly the australian flag with out the union Jack in the top left corner reason i ask I Dont want to but i know someone who is
	I am a member of the AML, and I wish to make an enquiry. I think we should ask Her Majesty, the Queen to visit Australia once more before she is unfit to travel. I think Her Majesty's presence would make the people happy and enliven the sense of monarchy into there hearts even the youth. The AML should speak to the Her Excellency, the Governor-General and the High Comissioner to Australia/the Ambassador to the United Kingdom and of course Her Majesty, herself. I think she should visit the major capital cities Sydney, Canberra, Brisbane and Perth.
	Reference the article 'Matters of Allegiance', does our Queen have Australian citizenship? Thought not. Cheers guys.
	Regarding organisations that have the word 'royal' at the start of their name. Such as Royal North Shore Hospital, and Royal Institute for Deaf & Blind. Can you tell me if that title has been given to them by the British Monarchy? Were they required to request the title from the British Monarchy? If the title is approved by the Monarchy, does it also assist those organisations financially. Regards, Amanda
	In view of the large (not yet quite a minority) of non-brits in Australia, surely the time will soon be upon Australia to remove the Union Jack from the Australian flag?
	What an absolute farce. A foul mouthed Scottish tennis player becomes an Officer of the Order of the British Empire for winning a tennis tournament. How low can these Queen's honours go? It also begs the question why only the British gold medallists are honoured. What about the Aussie gold medallists. After all she is supposed to be the Queen of Aus. Please bring on the Republic. By the way I am a tennis loving grandmother.
	I was born in Scotland but have resided in Australia for the past 64 years but I have not become an Australian Citizen as I am proud to be. a Scot and I have all the rights as an Australian Citizen. Does this mean I a ineligible to be a member of the AML?
	There is an error here. You refer to the Union Flag as the Union Jack - it is notable that this is incorrect. The Union Flag is only referred to as a "Jack" when flown at sea, from a ship. At any other time, it is simply called "the Union Flag"
	the queen has just been given a 100,000.00 pound per week increase in her allowance. is that some kind of joke? especially when pommyland is just about broke & pensioners & vulnerable people are having money taken from their allowances. royals belong in the dark ages. if only the eureka rebellion had been successful as in america.

Ask us a question: